Intial Commit

tools/reviewed-matches.json

@@ -0,0 +1,62 @@
+{
+  "reviewBasis": "Reviewed installed tile properties, actual 2D sprite contact sheets, model manifests and Viewpoint renderer bytecode. Approve only object-compatible model reuse. Never infer identity from the tile number alone.",
+  "matches": {
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_8": {
+      "source": "location_military_generic_01_0",
+      "adaptation": "gray-green-crate",
+      "tint": "#626763",
+      "expectedTargetCustomName": "Crate",
+      "expectedSourceCustomName": "Crate",
+      "evidence": "User-requested gray crate appearance: use the matching green crate mesh, retint its atlas toward #626763, and preserve luminance detail and transparency."
+    },
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_9": {
+      "source": "location_military_generic_01_1",
+      "adaptation": "gray-green-crate",
+      "tint": "#626763",
+      "expectedTargetCustomName": "Crate",
+      "expectedSourceCustomName": "Crate",
+      "evidence": "Second gray crate orientation uses the second green crate mesh with the same requested gray-green base tint."
+    },
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_16": {
+      "source": "location_military_generic_01_8",
+      "adaptation": "white-crate",
+      "expectedTargetCustomName": "Crate",
+      "expectedSourceCustomName": "Crate",
+      "evidence": "Knox white crate has the same military-crate shape as gray crate orientation 8. Reuse that crate mesh with a neutral white atlas. Vanilla index 16 is a military sign and is explicitly rejected. Color is an approximation; custom paint tint is not supplied by this pack."
+    },
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_17": {
+      "source": "location_military_generic_01_9",
+      "adaptation": "white-crate",
+      "expectedTargetCustomName": "Crate",
+      "expectedSourceCustomName": "Crate",
+      "evidence": "Same reviewed military-crate mesh for the second orientation; neutral white atlas. Vanilla index 17 is a sign, not a crate."
+    }
+  },
+  "extraSprites": {
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_2": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_2","method":"reviewed-stack"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_3": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_3","method":"reviewed-stack"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_4": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_4","method":"reviewed-stack"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_5": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_5","method":"reviewed-stack"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_10": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_2","method":"reviewed-stack","adaptation":"gray-green-crate","tint":"#626763"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_11": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_3","method":"reviewed-stack","adaptation":"gray-green-crate","tint":"#626763"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_12": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_4","method":"reviewed-stack","adaptation":"gray-green-crate","tint":"#626763"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_13": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_5","method":"reviewed-stack","adaptation":"gray-green-crate","tint":"#626763"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_18": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_10","method":"reviewed-stack","adaptation":"white-crate"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_19": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_11","method":"reviewed-stack","adaptation":"white-crate"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_20": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_12","method":"reviewed-stack","adaptation":"white-crate"},
+    "kbw_location_military_generic_01_21": {"source":"location_military_generic_01_13","method":"reviewed-stack","adaptation":"white-crate"}
+  },
+  "unmatchedReviews": [
+    {"pattern":"overlay_graffiti_wall_.*", "reason":"Reviewed wall-paint/sign overlay family. These are surface artwork, not standalone 3D objects. No matching authored mesh is needed to retain the art on its wall, and substituting a furniture mesh would be incorrect."},
+    {"pattern":"fixtures_bathroom_.*", "reason":"Reviewed attached bathroom fixture/overlay. No accepted authored asset with matching dimensions and artwork; retain native attachment behavior."},
+    {"pattern":"walls_.*", "reason":"Reviewed architectural wall/trim/pillar family. No accepted authored asset with matching shape and artwork; many variants rely on cut/edge/depth rendering. Do not substitute a furniture mesh or a differently shaped window wall."},
+    {"pattern":"fixtures_doors_.*", "reason":"Reviewed doors/open states/frame trims. Similar names or adjacent indices do not prove the same door or opening angle. Preserve Viewpoint door rendering; no accepted replacement asset."},
+    {"pattern":"fixtures_windows_.*", "reason":"Reviewed specialized window shape. Other window meshes are not guaranteed to match this shape, facing or broken/open state. Preserve native rendering; bespoke geometry would be needed for a faithful authored replacement."},
+    {"pattern":"fixtures_railings_.*", "reason":"Reviewed railing contact sheet. Unmatched sloped stair tips/posts are distinct sections of multi-tile railings, not duplicate full railing models. Substituting a full model here would duplicate or misalign the railing."},
+    {"pattern":"fixtures_fireplaces_.*", "reason":"Reviewed double-fireplace sprite footprint. Its halves form a two-tile opening; other fireplace/chimney models have different dimensions. Preserve existing edge/depth rendering rather than place a whole fireplace on each half."},
+    {"pattern":"signs_.*", "reason":"Reviewed sign family. No accepted authored model with the target sign artwork/size. Similar sign geometry alone would display a different business or sign."},
+    {"pattern":"location_.*", "reason":"Reviewed location-specific facade/sign/fixture family. No accepted equivalent model with this artwork and footprint; no cross-object substitution applied."},
+    {"pattern":"fencing_.*", "reason":"Reviewed fence and corner sections. Distinct corner/end geometry must remain separate; native edge rendering is retained where metadata exists."},
+    {"pattern":"street_.*", "reason":"Reviewed road/curb family. These are terrain overlays or curb sections, not furniture. No accepted authored replacement with the same section geometry."}
+  ]
+}